Use empathy and invention to help the main character(s) of a story.
A Kindergarten teacher was getting to know her young learners and spent time each day sharing books through read-alouds that she knew her learners would love, while engaging them in thoughtful discussions with prompts, before, during, and after reading. As the year progressed, she wanted to layer in new tasks related to the stories they were sharing each day.
As a next step, the teacher decided to introduce the idea of picture book engineering, which encourages readers to start from a place of empathy, focusing on what the main character in the story desires or needs as the reader works to find ways to help.
Novel (or picture book) engineering is an innovative approach to integrating engineering and literacy across all grades. Learners use literature (stories, novels, or expository texts) to inspire an engineering design challenge that allows them to identify problems, design solutions, and engage in the design thinking process (or creative process) while using their literacy skills. Learner thinking is driven by a lens of empathy as they aspire to support the character(s) in their text with their problem or goal, and work to produce a solution.
The teacher decided to use the book Knuffle Bunny by Mo Willems, one of the learners’ favourite authors. Knuffle Bunny is the story of Trixie, who accidently leaves her favourite stuffed animal behind at the laundromat. She is very distraught, but because she can’t talk yet, she can’t explain to her dad why she is so upset or why she needs to go back to the laundromat.
After reading the first part of the story to the class, the teacher paused and asked the learners to describe Trixie (including both physical and traits and characteristics) as they created a character profile and the teacher recorded it. Next, she asked the learners to describe Trixie’s problem in the story. The learners decided that Trixie’s problem was that she had lost her favourite stuffed animal but she couldn’t tell her dad.
After that, the teacher asked the learners to come up with ideas to help Trixie. She began to walk them through the stages of the design thinking process, using the TMI Robot (Think Make Improve) from Invent to Learn by Stager and Martinez. First, the teacher had them Think and brainstorm for possible solutions to Trixie’s problems as she recorded their creative thinking, using both words and pictures on the board.
The learners’ suggestions in the Think phase included ideas such as the following:
In the next phase of the lesson, the learners were asked to choose one idea they thought was best and were tasked with building or designing it using classroom supplies, including both art and building materials. In this Make phase, learners worked together to share ideas, work through differences, and complete their design idea as a team.
When the learners were done designing and building, they met as a class and talked through some of their classmates’ example creations, offering feedback on how they might Improve their design or solution to Trixie’s problem. They then met in small groups with adult support to talk through some more of the examples, to ask questions, and to offer their thinking.
To end, the learners had the opportunity to hear how the story ended and compare it to their imaginative solutions. They were relieved to see Knuffle Bunny and Trixie be reunited!
In Phase 2 of the learning experience, the class can read the sequels entitled Knuffle Bunny Too in which Knuffle Bunny gets mixed up with one of Trixie’s classmate’s stuffed animals, or Knuffle Bunny Free, in which Knuffle Bunny gets lost again, but this time on a trip to visit Trixie’s grandparents in Holland.
In this phase, the learners work in groups to come up with potential solutions to solve the character’s problem and brainstorm for three ideas in their small group (Think). Next, they decide as a group which idea they think is best and they move forward with (Make). Finally, they share their designs with another group to generate feedback before making these improvements to their creations (Improve).
(Some potential solutions: lost posters, tracking devices, magic wands that make stuffed bunnies reappear, find my Stuffed Animal app, etc.)
Martinez, Sylvia Libow, and Gary S. Stager. Invent to Learn: Making, Tinkering, and Engineering in the Classroom. Constructing Modern Knowledge Press, 2013.
Willems, Mo. Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Tale. Hyperion Books for Children, 2004.
———. Knuffle Bunny Free: An Unexpected Diversion. Balzer + Bray, 2010.
———. Knuffle Bunny Too: A Case of Mistaken Identity. Walker Books Ltd., 2008.